Why Eye Contact Feels So Tricky—And Simple Fixes That Help

Getty Images/iStockphoto

Eye contact sounds simple enough—just look at someone while they’re talking, right? But for a lot of people, it’s way more complicated than that. It can feel awkward, intense, or downright stressful. Sometimes it’s a confidence thing, sometimes it’s sensory, sometimes it’s just years of habit. Whatever the reason, there are ways to make eye contact feel less weird and more natural, without feeling like you’re forcing it or playing a staring contest.

1. It feels too intense or exposing.

For some people, making direct eye contact feels like they’re being seen too clearly, almost like emotional X-ray vision. It’s vulnerable, and that can be uncomfortable if you’re used to hiding how you feel. Try softening your gaze instead of locking eyes. Look at the bridge of their nose or between their eyebrows. It gives the same effect without feeling so raw.

2. You overthink it in the moment.

The second you start thinking, “Am I doing this right?” you lose all sense of what’s natural. Your brain spirals, and then you’re stuck in a weird loop of looking away and back again. Instead, shift your focus to the conversation. Let the eye contact happen while you’re genuinely listening, not while you’re analysing your every blink.

3. You’ve learned to avoid it socially.

If you grew up in an environment where looking adults in the eye was seen as disrespectful or confrontational, it might feel unnatural now, even though it’s expected in many social settings. Reframing it as connection rather than challenge can help. You’re not doing something wrong; you’re just unlearning a different set of rules.

4. It clashes with neurodivergent comfort levels.

For a lot of neurodivergent people, eye contact can feel physically uncomfortable or distracting. It’s not about shyness or rudeness; it’s a genuine sensory overwhelm. Focus on active listening instead. Nodding, summarising, and using facial expressions show engagement just as well as direct eye contact ever could.

5. You’re afraid of being misread.

Some people worry their eye contact will be misinterpreted—too flirty, too intense, too cold, too much. So they avoid it altogether to dodge the risk of sending the “wrong” message. The fix here is practice and feedback. Ask a trusted friend how your eye contact comes across. You’ll probably find you’re doing fine, and hearing that out loud helps build confidence.

6. You zone out when people talk.

Not in a rude way—your brain just wanders. And when it does, eye contact naturally drops. By the time you snap back to attention, you feel like you’ve messed up socially. Keep a small part of your focus anchored by noticing something visual—their jacket pattern, a gesture, a movement. It helps ground you in the moment without locking into full eye contact the entire time.

7. You’re relying too much on scripted interactions.

If you tend to plan out what you’ll say instead of responding naturally, your eyes might drift as you mentally rehearse. That makes it harder to stay present, and maintain steady eye contact. Try using open-ended questions to shift your attention back to the other person. It’s easier to make eye contact when you’re genuinely curious about their response instead of rehearsing your own.

8. You’re tired or emotionally drained.

Low energy levels can make everything feel harder, and eye contact is no exception. It’s one of the first things to go when your emotional bandwidth is running on fumes. Give yourself grace on rough days. Even short bursts of eye contact during key moments, like greetings or goodbyes, can make a difference and feel more manageable.

9. You grew up without seeing it modelled.

If eye contact wasn’t part of your upbringing—maybe your parents avoided it or weren’t big on face-to-face conversation—it makes sense that it wouldn’t come naturally to you now. That’s not a character flaw. You’re just working with a different baseline. You can learn it like any other social skill, one relaxed chat at a time.

10. You feel self-conscious about your face.

Some people avoid eye contact because they don’t want other people looking too closely at them, whether it’s acne, ageing, or just general self-consciousness. The worry becomes a wall. Work on reframing it: most people are thinking about themselves, not inspecting you. You’re a lot more relaxed-looking to other people than you feel inside.

11. You’re worried about making other people uncomfortable.

Some people avoid eye contact out of concern for the other person. “What if they think I’m staring?” “What if I seem intense?” That over-accommodation can block real connection. Start with brief glances while smiling or nodding. Friendly eye contact isn’t invasive; it’s how people feel seen. Trust that most people find it reassuring, not unsettling.

12. You’re in a rush all the time.

When your brain’s on fast-forward, you don’t pause long enough to connect, including with your eyes. Conversations become transactions, and you’re already halfway out the door in your mind. Slow down a little. Even a few seconds of focused, calm eye contact can turn a rushed interaction into a proper human moment.

13. You’ve been burned by past reactions.

If someone’s made you feel awkward, judged, or dismissed for how you look or behave during eye contact, it sticks. You start avoiding the risk altogether. Of course, not everyone’s like that person. Give yourself a fresh start with people who make you feel safe, and rebuild the habit in low-pressure spaces first.

14. You’re not breathing properly.

It sounds silly, but holding your breath or breathing shallowly while making eye contact makes you feel more nervous. Your body goes into mini panic mode, and everything feels ten times harder. Focus on breathing slowly and evenly during conversations. It relaxes your muscles and helps eye contact feel less like a spotlight and more like part of the flow.

15. You’re trying too hard to do it “right”

When you treat eye contact like a performance—how long, how often, what angle—it stops feeling natural. You turn it into a rulebook instead of a rhythm. Try thinking of eye contact as part of being curious and present, not a test to pass. It doesn’t need to be perfect, just real. Real is always more effective than rehearsed.